The Deal
Sunday, November 22, 
7:58 am

Dealwatch: Pharmacies

  Share     E-Mail    Discussion (1)     Print Story
110106_cvs-caremark.jpgCompetition to become the nation's top pharmacy gave way earlier this year to competition to take top billing among pharmacy benefits companies.

CVS Corp. and Caremark Rx Inc. gained shareholder approval for their $26 billion merger March 15 and 16 (respectively) -- a union that prescription benefits giant Express Scripts Inc. has been trying to scuttle for months. Though it lost out, the bidding worked in ES' favor. Interest from CVS renewed investor interest in prescription benefits managers in general and for ES specifically: its shares were up from $69.97 when it first went after Caremark in December, to $82.39 on Friday, writes The Deal's Lisa Gewirtz-Ward.

Continue reading below

Also on Dealscape

ONE CONTENTIOUS YEAR

ES tweaked its offer for Caremark March 7, ahead of a second request for information by the Federal Trade Commission.

Express Scripts unveiled plans to bolster its $26.1 billion bid by paying 6% interest on the $29.25 a share cash consideration of the offer beginning April 1 and running through the deal's close or 45 days past antitrust clearance, whichever arrived first. Though it ultimately failed, the stock component of ES' offer equated to 0.426 shares of its own stock and was worth about $61.12 a share March 7. Hours later, CVS bettered its own offer, increasing a $6 special dividend payable to shareholders to $7.50 a share, effectively raising its offer to nearly $60 a share.

ES' move March 7 was an attempt to woo Caremark shareholders, while the company has stood stalwart in favor of a tie up with CVS. CVS bettered its offer for Caremark in mid-February to about $25.5 billion for the company, boosting its dividend to $6 a share, but still drew fire from shareholder groups, despite Caremark's requests for support.

The increased offer came weeks after Woonsocket, R.I.-based CVS and Nashville-based Caremark said the target's stockholders would receive a one-time $2 dividend per share after the merger's close and that 150 million outstanding shares in the new company would be retired. Express Scripts called the move "no more than a desperate attempt to save a flawed transaction," hours after the formal launch of its own hostile offer.

 

The harsh response from Express Scripts came a month after the spoiler launched its initial bid and weeks after having filed for antitrust clearance Jan. 4, 2007--kicking off a showdown with CVS.

Days after the January showdown began, Caremark rejected Express Scripts' advance, saying its board concluded the proposal wouldn't likely lead to a superior offer. Express Scripts then said it would nominate a slate of four directors to Caremark's board.

CVS first unveiled plans in November 2006 that it would spread its wings into pharmacy benefits with a $21 billion play for Caremark. The proposed CVS-Caremark tie-up has already passed regulatory muster and in a statement Jan. 7, Caremark said it would "most effectively address the rapidly changing dynamics of today's healthcare system."

For CVS, the deal also signals a new way for the company to bulk up, two months after rival Rite-Aid Corp. secured its own No.1 spot among drugstores on the East Coast with its $3.4 billion purchase of Jean Coutu Group Inc. on Aug. 24.

MINDING THE COUNTER

The Federal Trade Commission issued a second request for information on the proposed Rite-Aid-Jean Coutu tie-up in October. The deal enabled the Camp Hill, Pa.-based chain to add 1,858 drug stores under the Eckerd and Brooks brands and march into Massachusetts, Rhode Island, North Carolina and South Carolina.

Though it has certainly drawn scrutiny, the deal isn't expected to suffer the same fate as Rite-Aid's 1996 bid for Revco D.S. Inc., which, Dealwatchers say, faced opposition because of the possibility pharmacy benefit managers seeking contracts with pharmacy chains to offer discounts as part of insurance packages wouldn't be able to negotiate for lower prices from a combined Rite Aid-Revco. But with new players in the pharmacy business, like Target and Wal-Mart, competition should be able to prevail.

CLOSE CIRCLES

The proposed Rite-Aid-Jean Coutu deal comes just six years after Rite-Aid averted bankruptcy and two years after its $4 billion bid for the entire Eckerd Corp. chain proved unsuccessful, when then-seller J.C. Penney Co. realized it could reap more dividing up the struggling chain and selling off the pieces to Jean Coutu and CVS--$525 million more.

The larger pool of bidders reportedly included private equity firms Blackstone Group and Thomas H. Lee Partners LP, who walked away in early 2004.

  • While experienced acquirer CVS integrated its new 1,260 stores well, Jean Coutu's new 1,540 shops, which transformed the Canadian group into the No. 4 drug store in North America, proved a tougher pill to swallow.

Sources told The Deal Aug. 24 that Jean Coutu discussed the latest deal only with Rite-Aid. The new company will have annual sales of about $26.8 billion and about 5,000 stores in 31 states and the District of Columbia.

NEXT, PLEASE

Alongside CVS, Walgreen Co. also continues to surpass No.3 Rite-Aid. Walgreen made some deal announcements in 2006, but a big-ticket purchase for the group might be imminent.--Carolyn Murphy

Dealwatch executive summary
The Date
The Action
3.16.07 Caremark shareholders OK CVS buyout. Express Scripts retreats.
3.07.07 Express Scripts sweetens its Caremark offer. Hours later, CVS follows suit.
2.26.07 Caremark vote delayed, for the second time.
2.13.07 CVS boosts Caremark offer to $25.5 billion.
1.23.07 Caremark pushes for shareholder approval of its planned merger with CVS.
1.16.07 CVS/Caremark agree to special dividend. Express Scripts says it's desperate.
1.16.07 Express Scripts launches Caremark tender offer.
1.08.07 Express Scripts plans to nominate a slate of 4 to Caremark's board.
1.07.07 Caremark rejects Express Scripts' advance.
1.04.07 Express Scripts files for antitrust clearance.
12.18.06 Express Scripts offers $26 billion for Caremark, trying to scuttle its $21 billion sale to CVS.
11.01.06 CVS makes $21 billion play for Caremark. What will the regulators say?
10.18.06 The FTC issues a second request for information on the proposed deal.
8.24.06 Rite-Aid bags Jean Coutu. (See related deal memo)
8.24.06 The deal may draw scrutiny, but the pharmacy world is a changin'.
7.13.06 CVS bags MinuteClick.
1.2006 Dealwatchers examine the different outcomes for CVS and Jean Coutu.
1.2006 Albertson's auction is finally over; CVS takes home Osco, Sav-On.
4.06.04 J.C. Penney decides to divide Eckerd in two. (See related deal memo)
2.12.04 J.C. Penney tries to bolster Eckerd bids with promise of a larger tax write-off, sources told The Deal.
2.12.04 PE firms walk away from Eckerd.
1.26.04 The auction began to stall as Eckerd's revenue continued to fall.
12.07.01 Jean Coutu grabbed 80 Osco stores for $240 million.
08.2001 Rite-Aid averts bankruptcy.

Source: The Deal




Comments

From: Compounding Pharmacist,

Compound Pharmacy has gained much popularity in the field of medicine. The medications are equally effective and safe for sick patients who cannot take the actual medications due to their personal allergies.


Post a comment





The Deal Pipeline

Deal Video


Inside The Deal: Avaya Inc.'s Mohamad Ali on the company's next target.


More video...

Crisis On Wall Street
Technology
Deals of The Decade

Community

Industry Insight

Managing your shareholder base

Growth companies and their PE sponsors should be wary of the pitfalls that arise when they layer on tiers of preferred stock.


Industry Insight

Easing the stress of distressed M&A

Corporate buyers face numerous complexities when trying to identify the right moment to purchase a distressed asset.


Editor's Note

Editor's letter: Nov. 16, 2009

Beneath the veneer of Wall Streeters beats the same heart, stirred by the same determinants of behavior.


footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg


©Copyright 2009, The Deal, LLC. All rights reserved. Please send all technical questions, comments or concerns to the Webmaster.