The Deal
Sunday, November 8, 
1:07 pm

Strine: Flowers has the weaker argument

  Share     E-Mail    Discussion    Print Story

Delaware Vice Chancellor Leo E. Strine Jr. was in no hurry to interject himself into the fight between SLM Corp. and Christopher Flowers Monday afternoon. The Delaware judge declined to accelerate SLM's suit against Flowers, since both parties are free to walk from the deal and the only remedy available to SLM is the $900 million breakup fee Flowers, Bank of America Corp. and J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. would owe if they withdraw from the deal without cause.

The cause they're claiming, of course, is a material adverse effect at SLM. Strine hinted late in Monday's scheduling conference that SLM has the better of the argument there. The judge said: "The weakness from [the defendants'] position is this idea that one penny on top of what is outlined in the agreement makes you count the whole thing as an MAE. This is not intuitively the most obvious reading of [the MAE definition in the agreement]. On the other hand, the plaintiffs' position could have been much more clearly drafted if they wished to say that, essentially, all the legislation was a baseline, and you measure the incremental effect. I'm not sure that this is the greatest example of clear scrivening from either side."

That language may give Flowers and friends a slight nudge to settle in order to avoid paying the $900 million reverse breakup fee in the deal. But by refusing to hear SLM's case on the MAE issue in the next month, Strine essentially left the parties to their own devices.

Full coverage will come later in The Daily Deal and on TheDeal.com. — David Marcus

Continue reading below

Also on Dealscape





Post a comment





The Deal Pipeline

Deal Video


Inside The Deal: Linklaters' Schmidt says how regulators handled Pfizer Inc.'s acquisition of Wyeth is an outlier of how others merger reviews will be conducted.


More video...

Crisis On Wall Street
Technology
Deals of The Decade

Community

Industry Insight

Dealing with frozen bank lending

If your bank is not willing to lend, what can you do as your company continues to seek growth?


Judgment Call

The coming age of the renminbi

The Chinese currency will play an increasingly important role in international commerce and finance.


Industry Insight

Banking on PE investments

Howls of protest greeted the FDIC policy statement, but the financial services industry should get over it.


footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg


©Copyright 2009, The Deal, LLC. All rights reserved. Please send all technical questions, comments or concerns to the Webmaster.