But now the independent inspector of elections has put out its report detailing that four of five TCI nominees won election to the board at the company's June 25 annual meeting.
If the appeals court upholds the District Court finding that TCI violated securities laws, it could disqualify many votes TCI cast in favor of the dissident slate by "sterilizing" or disqualify the portion of shares TCI owned while it was allegedly in violation of the disclosure rules. In total, that means 6.4% of TCI's stake could be ruled ineligible.
That would mean dissident directors Christopher Hohn, TCI founder, and Timothy T. O'Toole would have lost the election. According to the inspector of elections, Hohn received 130,506,157 votes, edging out incumbent director Frank Royal, who only got 129,715,745, a margin of about 0.3%. Hohn would definitely not have won had 6.4% of his TCI stake been removed. O'Toole also won with less than 6.4%.
The court isn't likely to rule until September, with oral Arguments scheduled for Aug. 25.
CSX is betting that if the court decides to sterilize those TCI shares it will be easier to keep Hohn and O'Toole off if they are never seated in the first place than if they have to remove them from their seats retroactively.
But until the court acts, what happens to fiduciary duty to shareholders? Hohn and O'Toole could end up losing up to 20% of their term as directors. Will the two dissidents receive an extra few months at the end of their 12 month term if the court doesn't decide to disqualify the votes? Also, what about the two directors Hohn and O'Toole are set to replace? Are Royal and William Richardson off the board yet? - Ron Orol
Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.
Railroad company CSX Corp. still refuses to seat two of four dissident director nominees, partly because the company hopes an appeals court ruling will disqualify a block of shares voted by the activist dissident investor Children's Investment Fund Management (UK) LLP. 
