The Deal
Saturday, November 7, 
10:07 pm

Searching for signs of the dreaded 'D' word

  Share     E-Mail    Discussion    Print Story
Time magazine cover from October 13 2008

The latest issue of Time magazine features a photo of a 1930s soup line with the words "The New Hard Times" emblazoned across it, asking in smaller print whether we've reached "The End of Prosperity?" Curiously enough, the word depression, the dreaded "D" word, appears in smaller type near the bottom of the cover, and is easy to miss. Ready for the gas pipe now? Well, as dire as that cover seems, the story it refers to, by Harvard professor Niall Ferguson, offers a very different picture. It turns out that Ferguson is no Nouriel Roubini, the New York University economist commonly referred to as Dr. Doom.

In other words, Time is engaging in depression chic. And in fact nothing concentrates the mind more than images of soup lines, apples sellers and Okies fleeing the dust bowl. So prepare yourself.

Continue reading below

Also on Dealscape

Ferguson's Time story tries to explain the causes of the Great Depression in an easily digestible form. Fergusson argues that one of the biggest policy mistakes was the initial inertia of the Federal Reserve to act at all. Instead of loosening, it tightened credit, triggering massive bank failures. Ferguson then contrasts this inaction with today. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke famously studied the Great Depression, and has taken an activist approach, which Ferguson terms the Great Repression.

Is Bernanke's Great Repression really working to stave off what Ferguson calls Depression 2.0? He seems to think so, though other academics don't agree. 

A report from the International Monetary Fund is warning the world that the U.S. is in store for a bad recession. The IMF report offers a stark view of where we may be heading. According to the blog Real Time Economics, Charles Collyns, deputy director of the IMF research department, said in a briefing that it's clear "that we are seeing the most dangerous shock to the mature financial markets since the 1930s, posing a major threat to global growth."

Like Time, Collyns alludes to the Depression, but he doesn't predict one. So what's the difference between a bad recession and a mild depression? The National Bureau of Economic Research, or NBER, defines a recession as:

A significant decline in economic activity spread across the economy, lasting more than a few months, normally visible in real GDP, real income, employment, industrial production, and wholesale-retail sales.

Now, consider an economic textbook definition of a depression:

Depression is characterized by unusual increases in unemployment, restriction of credit, shrinking output and investment, price deflation or hyperinflation, numerous bankruptcies, reduced amounts of trade and commerce, as well as violent currency devaluations.

Luckily, we can only answer yes to a small number of those signs.

  • We certainly have an increase in unemployment as evidenced by Friday's Labor Department report, but not anywhere near the levels -- over 20% -- of the Great Depression.
  • We  have numerous bankruptcies, and they are increasing, but they're not extremely high
  • We also have a clear restriction of credit with LIBOR reaching a nine-month high of 4.33%
  • And while the CPI may not point to deflation, the price of homes -- where most Americans have their wealth tied up in -- are falling like bricks across the country, and even the price at the pump has been on a steady decline for the last few weeks
However, what we haven't witnessed -- yet -- is a sharp shrinkage in productivity, output and trade, nor the more unusual economic circumstances, at least for the U.S., of extreme events: currency devaluations, deflation or hyperinflation.

But if there is a silver lining -- for Wall Street at least -- in media and academics throwing around the "D" word, it may be that it helped to sway some House members to change their vote on Friday leading to the approval of the $700 billion bailout bill. But is that the silver bullet that will solve the crisis and avert a depression or a Japanese-style Lost Decade that the IMF warns about? Well, it really depends on who you ask. Some have warned that the bailout could lead to unintended consequences that could add more check marks on our depression check list.

Take for example Nobel economist and former Clinton economic adviser and IMF chief economist Joseph Stiglitz, who wrote about the bailout:

The unemployment rate will still increase, growth will remain anemic, house prices will continue to fall, the number of houses in foreclosure will continue to rise, credit will be harder to get, states and localities will remain in a fiscal crisis, and there will be cutbacks in basic public services. ... Our living standards in the future will be lower than they otherwise would have been.

It certainly sounds as if he's checking everything off on the list, though he's not clear how bad each of those maladies will prove to be.

Stiglitz isn't the only academic blogging advice. Nearly every day Roubini offers another reason why House members were right to oppose the bill the first time around on his Web site RGE Monitor.

As for the folks at the IMF, they refuse to address the topic directly until next week's World Economic Outlook summit. Don't be surprised if some of them use the dreaded "D" word. - Matthew Wurtzel

Matthew Wurtzel is the editor of Dealscape.





Post a comment





The Deal Pipeline

Deal Video


Inside The Deal: Linklaters' Schmidt says how regulators handled Pfizer Inc.'s acquisition of Wyeth is an outlier of how others merger reviews will be conducted.


More video...

Crisis On Wall Street
Technology
Deals of The Decade

Community

Industry Insight

Dealing with frozen bank lending

If your bank is not willing to lend, what can you do as your company continues to seek growth?


Judgment Call

The coming age of the renminbi

The Chinese currency will play an increasingly important role in international commerce and finance.


Industry Insight

Banking on PE investments

Howls of protest greeted the FDIC policy statement, but the financial services industry should get over it.


footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg footspacer.jpg


©Copyright 2009, The Deal, LLC. All rights reserved. Please send all technical questions, comments or concerns to the Webmaster.