Subscriber Content Preview | Request a free trialSearch  
  Go

The Deal Magazine

   Request magazine  |  Subscribe to newsletter
Print  |  Share  |  Discuss  |  Reprint

Bankruptcy league tables

by KImberly Ghorm  |  Published March 15, 2012 at 12:00 PM

Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. may have collapsed in an epic spectacle more than three years ago, but for many restructuring advisers, the case is the gift that keeps on giving. Don't expect that to change anytime soon, either.

When debtors win confirmation of Chapter 11 plans -- as Lehman Brothers did in December -- or firms file their final fee applications, The Deal Pipeline typically closes the assignments, and their impact vanishes from the quarterly bankruptcy league tables. Lehman Brothers, though, is no ordinary debtor. It appears that most firms on the case, the largest by assets or liabilities in U.S. history, will still need to wrap up work long after the one-time brokerage and investment bank's liquidation plan goes into effect, which occurred on March 6.

The ideal example of this phenomenon: Alvarez & Marsal LLC.

"Now that plan confirmation is behind us, the focus has shifted to emergence, the post-effective board's due diligence and getting distributions paid to creditors," says A&M managing director John Suckow, also president and COO of Lehman Brothers. "A&M is expected to continue to work on the case post-emergence. Our role to manage the estate has not changed. There are still substantial assets to sell, substantial claims to mitigate and substantial responsibility to distribute cash, and that will continue for some time."

The firm (No. 3 among crisis management firms in the fourth quarter, with 31 cases) has greatly benefited from working on Lehman Brothers. It collected $512 million in fees and expenses through November, court papers show, with a sizable team engaged in roles from the C-suite (such as Suckow and A&M co-CEO Bryan Marsal, who doubles as Lehman's CEO) to forensic technology, real estate, loans and international operations. As the case begins to wind down, though, fewer advisers are at work.

"A&M has been decreasing both its fees and full-time employees on Lehman over the course of the bankruptcy," Suckow says. "Fees peaked in mid-2009 [they hit $18.55 million that June], and about 100 people have been redeployed to other assignments since then. This trend is expected to continue."

On the legal side, Chadbourne & Parke LLP (No. 24, 70 cases) is one of many on the case that will continue to provide representation for clients several quarters after Lehman's emergence. (Debtor counsel Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, which received $352.9 million through May for work on the case and seeks an additional $39.9 million in fees and expenses for June through September, did not respond to requests for comment.)

"We represent 15 or more different creditors from all over the world that the Lehman estate owes," Chadbourne partner David LeMay says. "Clients have ongoing claims-reconciliation matters that will extend beyond the exit date, and we'll be working post-bankruptcy, because the end of a case does not necessarily mean that the work concludes."

When the firm's Lehman assignments do wrap up, LeMay says it won't put a dent in Chadbourne's caseload -- though it would hit hard in the volume ranking, where the firm is No. 13 ($897 billion in total assets). "The amount of work that we are doing for creditors in the Lehman case is not a significant percentage of our overall business."

Indeed, Chadbourne was retained for several fourth-quarter filings, including the Chapter 15 case of Jakarta, Indonesia, dry-bulk carrier PT. Arpeni Pratama Ocean Line Tbk. ($500 million in assets).

Crisis management firm Goldin Associates LLC (No. 10, 16 cases; third by volume, $699.8 billion) is back for a second helping of Lehman Brothers. Goldin executive managing director David Pauker (No. 9, 11 assignments) and his firm were engaged as a litigation consultant to James Giddens, trustee for Lehman Brothers Inc. in its liquidation under the Securities Investor Protection Act, with issues involving Barclays plc. That engagement, Pauker says, has been over for more than a year. Recently, though, Pauker was named one of seven directors that will oversee the liquidation of Lehman Brothers Holdings under its Chapter 11 plan.

Pauker explains that there is no connection between his new role as director and the earlier role as adviser. "In November, I was approached by Korn/Ferry on behalf of the selection committee and was asked to interview for a role as a director under the Lehman plan," he says. "The committee had been unaware of my firm's prior role but generally seemed to consider it a positive factor."

Pauker is the only restructuring adviser named to the post-effective-date board of Lehman and was previously chief restructuring officer for bankrupt brokerage Refco Inc. He and his firm are continuing to take on other new engagements, but Pauker acknowledges preparing for his new role isn't a snap. "I told my firm I was attending classes at Lehman for most of January but would be ready for new engagements once the new board has come up to speed."

In the fourth quarter, though, Pauker added an assignment as financial adviser to residential mortgage insurance provider PMI Group Inc. ($225 million). The new mandates shot Pauker 13 spots up the volume table in the fourth quarter to fourth place ($675.4 billion in assets).

But not all firms can keep a good thing going. Lazard (No. 5 among investment banks, 15 cases; first by volume, $711.9 billion) is one for which the exit of Lehman will officially mark the end of its assignment as M&A adviser to the investment bank. "Our engagement is technically done on consummation, and we will continue to work until that point," says Barry Ridings, vice chairman of U.S. investment banking at Lazard. "But billions in assets remain, and Lehman has to decide how to monetize those assets."

Ridings adds that Lazard is "continuously replacing completed assignments with new business." In the fourth quarter, Lazard added assignments such as Dynegy Holdings LLC ($13.8 billion) and General Maritime Corp. ($1.7 billion).

The size of those cases also hints at what could be in store for the entire restructuring community in the wake of Lehman. The fourth quarter saw the three largest bankruptcies of 2011 -- MF Global Holdings Ltd. ($41 billion), AMR Corp. ($24.7 billion) and Dynegy Holdings -- as well as five of the year's 10 largest Chapter 11 cases, which include General Maritime.

"Statistically, the third quarter of 2011 was the first recent quarter where large bankruptcy filings were up from the previous quarter, and the fourth quarter of 2011 was up from the third," A&M managing director Jeffery Stegenga says.

"Companies still have meaningful leverage that needs to be addressed. They are starting to look ahead and say, 'I've got some challenges.' The problem is further exacerbated by the fact that you have euro-zone issues overseas, which have an unsettling impact on the U.S. capital markets."

In such an environment, restructuring firms may have few problems saying goodbye to Lehman Brothers when the time comes.


LAW FIRMS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Law firm No. of active cases Avg. Assets Assets
1 Duane Morris LLP 188 $6.1 $1,150.6
2 Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP 93 12.1 1,126.9
3 Latham & Watkins LLP 136 8.3 1,125.0
4 Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP 65 17.1 1,110.5
5 Saul Ewing LLP 123 8.8 1,084.2
6 Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP 92 11.5 1,059.4
7 White & Case LLP 63 16.6 1,048.6
8 Reed Smith LLP 105 9.8 1,027.0
9 Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 94 10.5 990.5
10 Vedder Price PC 68 14.2 967.2
LAWYERS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Lawyer Law firm No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 Rosenberg, Robert Latham & Watkins LLP 37 $24.4 $901.9
2 Lauria, Thomas White & Case LLP 27 32.2 870.2
3 Gilhuly, Peter Latham & Watkins LLP 26 31 805.6
4 Hahn, Richard Debevoise & Plimpton LLP 15 53.5 802.7
Rapisardi, John Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft LLP 11 73 802.7
5 Gottfried, Andrew Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 10 80 800.4
6 Schaffer, Eric A. Reed Smith LLP 15 52.7 790.7
7 Davidson, Scott King & Spalding LLP 12 65.7 788
8 Lipke, Douglas Vedder Price PC 25 31.1 777
9 Caton, Amy Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP 5 154.4 771.8
10 Reisman, Steven Curtis, Mallet-Prevost, Colt & Mosle LLP 14 55 770.2
INVESTMENT BANKS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Bank No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 Lazard 12 $59.3 $711.9
2 Houlihan Lokey Inc. 17 39.1 665.0
3 Duff & Phelps Corp. 22 29.4 647.1
4 MM Dillon & Co. 2 320.6 641.3
5 Gleacher & Co. Securities Inc. 1 639.0 639.0
Natixis Capital Markets Inc. 1 639.0 639.0
6 Blackstone Group LP 13 5.9 77.1
7 Jefferies & Co. 15 3.0 44.4
8 Peter J. Solomon Co. 1 32.9 32.9
9 Navigant Capital Advisors LLC 13 2.1 27.3
10 Mesirow Financial Holdings Inc. 12 2.2 26.2
11 Rothschild 6 4.3 25.8
INVESTMENT BANKERS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Banker Bank No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 Ridings, Barry Lazard 4 $167.9 $671.6
2 Siegert, Eric Houlihan Lokey Inc. 3 217.7 653.2
3 Burian, Saul Houlihan Lokey Inc. 3 213.8 641.3
Espinal, M., Lambert, R. MM Dillon & Co. 2 320.6 641.3
4 Geer, Bradley Houlihan Lokey Inc. 2 319.7 639.4
5 Fazio, M.; Ma, C.; Putnam, D.; Zwick, A. Houlihan Lokey Inc. 1 639 639
Hayden, Chris Natixis Capital Markets Inc. 1 639 639
Pfeiffer, Allen Duff & Phelps Corp. 1 639 639
6 Zelin, Steve Blackstone Group LP 4 8.4 33.8
7 Maxwell, Anders Peter J. Solomon Co. 1 32.9 32.9
8 Gentile, Robert Blackstone Group LP 4 7.8 31.4
9 Lefkovits, Ari Lazard 2 15.1 30.2
10 Feuerabendt, Stefan Blackstone Group LP 1 1 30.1
CRISIS MANAGEMENT FIRMS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Firm No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 FTI Consulting Inc. 97 $9.8 $949.5
2 Capstone Advisory Group LLC 21 38.3 805
3 Goldin Associates LLC 9 77.8 699.8
4 Alvarez & Marsal LLC 31 22.2 687.2
5 Protiviti Inc. 14 2.1 29.8
6 Bain & Co. 1 24.7 24.7
7 Huron Consulting Group Inc. 15 1.3 20.1
8 AlixPartners LLP 12 0.9 10.7
9 XRoads Solutions Group LLC 5 0.7 3.4
10 Zolfo Cooper LLC 7 0.5 3.3
CRISIS MANAGERS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Manager Firm No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 Eisenband, Michael FTI Consulting Inc. 12 $67.3 $807.7
2 Tully, Conor FTI Consulting Inc. 8 95.4 763.4
3 Star, Samuel FTI Consulting Inc. 8 84.6 676.8
4 Pauker, David Goldin Associates LLC 8 84.4 675.4
5 Greenspan, Ronald FTI Consulting Inc. 15 44.7 670.1
6 Salomon, John Capstone Advisory Group LLC 4 159.8 639.2
7 Darefsky, R.; Hewitt, K. FTI Consulting Inc. 1 639 639
Marsal, Bryan Alvarez & Marsal LLC* 1 639 639
8 Kearns, Chris Capstone Advisory Group LLC 6 16.9 101.7
9 Selwood, Mike FTI Consulting Inc. 4 20.7 82.8
10 Phillips, Anna FTI Consulting Inc. 1 82.3 82.3
11 Conly, Albert FTI Consulting Inc. 11 6.3 68.8
12 Nolan, Bill FTI Consulting Inc. 9 7.6 68.6
*Alvarez & Marsal LLC team: Baldasare, T.; Cairns, A.; Cheston, P.; Cohn, S.; Cyburt, P.; Donaldson, J.; Ehrmann, D.; Fitts, J.; Fox, W.; Hershan, R.; Kruse, P.; Lakhani, A.; Lambert, D.; Lippman, M.; Marsal, B.; McCarthy, J.; Suckow, J.; Walsh, D.
NONINVESTMENT BANKS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Firm No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets ($B)
1 Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions LLC 115 $9.4 $1,078.3
2 BMC Group Inc. 78 9.6 748.3
3 Kekst and Co. 10 69.8 697.5
4 Kurtzman Carson Consultants LLC 157 2.2 338.8
5 Garden City Group Inc. 114 2.4 277.8
6 Deloitte 29 2.8 82.3
7 Ernst & Young 26 2.3 59.2
8 KPMG 8 6.5 51.6
9 J.H. Cohn LLP 12 3.3 39.6
10 Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher 4 8.7 34.7
NONINVESTMENT BANKERS, BY VOLUME ($B)
Rank Professional Firm No. of active cases Avg. assets Assets
1 McElhinney, Daniel Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions LLC 115 $9.4 $1,078.3
2 Feil, Tinamarie BMC Group Inc. 63 11.7 739.4
3 Weiner, Adam Kekst and Co. 2 331.9 663.7
4 Carson, J.; Kurtzman, E. Kurtzman Carson Consultants LLC 157 2.2 338.8
5 Stein, Jeffrey Garden City Group Inc. 86 2.8 239.4
6 Gerber, K.; Jacobs, R. Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions LLC 14 5.6 78.1
7 Blair, Kirk Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 2 22.2 44.4
8 Brimmer, A.; Siegel, A. Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher 3 11.5 34.6
9 Fielding, Jeremy Kekst and Co. 2 15.7 31.3
10 Zucker, Cliff J.H. Cohn LLP 4 6.7 26.8
11 Kriger, Kimberly Kekst and Co. 4 6.5 26.2
Includes all debtor, creditor and other assignments within active bankruptcy cases. All cases active as of Dec. 31, 2011.
The bankruptcy league tables by volume involve only active U.S. bankruptcy cases of debtors with assets of $10 miliion or more.

 

BANKRUPTCY LAW FIRMS, BY NUMBER
Rank Law firm No. of active cases Percent U.S. Percent non - U.S.
1 White & Case LLP 1,116 8% 92%
2 Duane Morris LLP 347 100 0
3 Ballard Spahr LLP 296 100 0
4 Latham & Watkins LLP 229 92 8
5 Saul Ewing LLP 175 99 1
6 Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 160 100 0
7 Reed Smith LLP 155 99 1
Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP 155 99 1
8 King & Spalding LLP 154 98 2
9 Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP 138 100 0
10 Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP 128 100 0
Richards, Layton & Finger PA 128 99 1
BANKRUPTCY LAWYERS, BY NUMBER
Rank Lawyer Law firm No. of active assignments
1 Pollack, David Ballard Spahr LLP 452
2 Leanse, Thomas J. Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP 348
3 Huben, Brian Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP 320
4 Bahr, Biner White & Case LLP 311
5 Schulte-Kaubruegger, Christoph White & Case LLP 203
6 Branch, Dustin Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP 188
7 Undritz, Sven-Holger White & Case LLP 169
8 Carr, James Kelley Drye & Warren LLP 164
9 Meyers, Jeffrey Ballard Spahr LLP 137
10 Minuti, Mark Saul Ewing LLP 106
INVESTMENT BANKS, BY NUMBER
Rank Bank No. of active cases Percent U.S. Percent non - U.S.
1 Duff & Phelps Corp. 24 92% 8%
2 Navigant Capital Advisors LLC 19 100 0
3 Houlihan Lokey Inc. 17 100 0
4 Jefferies & Co. 16 94 6
5 Lazard 15 85 15
6 Blackstone Group LP 14 100 0
General Capital Partners LLC 14 100 0
7 Mesirow Financial Holdings Inc. 13 100 0
8 Gordian Group LLC 11 100 0
9 BDO Capital Advisors LLC 8 100 0
Carl Marks Securities LLC 8 100 0
Moelis & Co. LLC 8 88 12
INVESTMENT BANKERS, BY NUMBER
Rank Banker Bank No. of active assignments
1 Barrow, J. Gregory General Capital Partners LLC 13
2 Casas, E., Luria, N. Navigant Capital Advisors LLC 11
3 Owsley, Henry Gordian Group LLC 9
4 Huber, Jack Navigant Capital Advisors LLC 8
Kaufman, Peter Gordian Group LLC 8
Williams, Brent Duff & Phelps Corp. 8
5 Manning, Jeffrey BDO Capital Advisors LLC 7
6 Caldwell, P., Herman, D. Gordian Group LLC 6
Madden, John Duff & Phelps Corp. 6
7 Cullen, B., Murphy, B. Duff & Phelps Corp. 5
Kurtz, D., Ridings, B. Lazard 5
Victor, J. Scott SSG Capital Advisors LLC 5
Wu, Christopher Carl Marks Securities LLC 5
CRISIS MANAGEMENT FIRMS, BY NUMBER
Rank Firm No. of active cases Percent U.S. Percent non-U.S.
1 FTI Consulting Inc. 224 54% 46%
2 GlassRatner Advisory & Capital Group LLC 109 99 1
3 Alvarez & Marsal LLC 39 79 21
4 MorrisAnderson & Associates Ltd. 31 100 0
5 NHB Advisors Inc. 30 100 0
Zolfo Cooper LLC 30 30 70
6 Protiviti Inc. 27 100 0
7 Development Specialists Inc. 25 100 0
8 Capstone Advisory Group LLC 22 100 0
9 Focus Management Group USA Inc. 19 100 0
10 Executive Sounding Board Associates Inc. 16 100 0
Goldin Associates LLC 16 100 0
CRISIS MANAGERS, BY NUMBER
Rank Manager Firm No. of active assignments
1 Fok, Vincent FTI Consulting Inc. 47
2 Glass, Ronald GlassRatner Advisory & Capital Group LLC 44
3 Arboit, Bruno FTI Consulting Inc. 36
4 Gavin, Edward T. NHB Advisors Inc. 27
5 Smith, Margaret GlassRatner Advisory & Capital Group LLC 23
6 Greenspan, Ronald FTI Consulting Inc. 22
7 Reiss, Freddie FTI Consulting Inc. 13
8 Atkinson, Michael Protiviti Inc. 12
Conly, A.; Eisenband, M.; Simms, S. FTI Consulting Inc. 12
Santoro, Thomas GlassRatner Advisory & Capital Group LLC 12
9 DuFrayne, M.; Katz, R. Executive Sounding Board Associates Inc. 11
Pauker, David Goldin Associates LLC 11
10 Goldstein, Charles Protiviti Inc. 10
Tucker, Michael FTI Consulting Inc. 10
11 Agarwal, Robert Executive Sounding Board Associates Inc. 9
Buenzow, M.; Cooper, K.; Nolan, B.;Tully, C. FTI Consulting Inc. 9
O'Keefe, Anne Zolfo Cooper LLC 9
NONINVESTMENT BANKS, BY NUMBER
Rank Firm* No. of active cases Percent U.S. Percent non-U.S.
1 Deloitte 1722 1% 99%
2 BDO Consulting 494 8 92
3 Kurtzman Carson Consultants LLC 183 100 0
4 Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions LLC 151 100 0
5 BMC Group Inc. 110 100 0
6 Garden City Group Inc. 107 99 1
7 PricewaterhouseCoopers 101 16 84
8 EisnerAmper LLP 91 100 0
9 Ernst & Young 80 22 78
10 KPMG 63 6 94
*Deloitte includes Deloitte & Touche Inc., Deloitte Financial Advisory Services LLP, Deloitte Tax LLP and Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu; Ernst & Young includes Ernst & Young Inc. and Ernst & Young LLP; KPMG includes KPMG Corporate Recovery, KPMG Inc. and KPMG LLP; PricewaterhouseCoopers includes PricewaterhouseCoopers EC Inc., PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. and PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
NONINVESTMENT BANKERS, BY NUMBER
Rank Professional Firm No. of active assignments
1 Carson, J., Kurtzman, E. Kurtzman Carson Consultants LLC 180
2 Lombe, David Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 155
3 Cussen, Neil Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 149
4 McElhinney, Daniel C. Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions LLC 144
5 Greig, John Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 114
6 Stein, Jeffrey S. Garden City Group Inc. 100
7 Feil, Tinamarie BMC Group Inc. 96
8 Wallace-Smith, Simon Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 85
9 Hernyk, Steven Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 52
10 Campbell, C., Hamel, D. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 46
Includes all debtor, creditor and other assignments within active bankruptcy cases. All assignments active as of Dec. 31, 2011.
Share:
Tags: Alvarez & Marsal LLC | AMR Corp. | bankruptcy | bankruptcy league tables | Barclays plc | Bryan Marsal | Chadbourne & Parke LLP | Chapter 11 | David LeMay | Goldin Associates LLC | John Suckow | Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. | MF Global Holdings Ltd. | PT. Arpeni Pratama Ocean Line Tbk. | Weil Gotshal & Manges LLP
blog comments powered by Disqus

Meet the journalists



Movers & Shakers

Launch Movers and shakers slideshow

Goldman, Sachs & Co. veteran Tracy Caliendo will join Bank of America Merrill Lynch in September as a managing director and head of Americas equity hedge fund services. For other updates launch today's Movers & shakers slideshow.

Video

Fewer deals despite discount debt

When will companies stop refinancing and jump back into M&A? More video

Sectors