The Deal
Monday, December 1, 
12:29 pm

by Paul Bonanos
[Posted on June 16, 2008 - 2:18 PM]

For seed-stage investors, the sweet spot is social media. The startups in the sector, from multimedia microblogging services to online communities for dog lovers, have very little overhead, taking full advantage of the Internet infrastructure built a decade ago by the previous generation of entrepreneurs and the widely available and free development tools generated by the open software movement.

Early-stage investors love social media companies in part because they are cheap to create, typically requiring less than $1 million to develop a product and bring it to market. Even Facebook Inc., with its multibillion-dollar valuation, subsisted on a $500,000 investment from PayPal Inc. co-founder Peter Thiel's Founders Fund of San Francisco before Sequoia Capital of Menlo Park, Calif., and Accel Partners of Palo Alto, Calif., delivered its first proper venture funding.

Most social media companies are still in their infancy, but there are already a few that received seed-stage backing three or four years ago and have already enjoyed exits. Photo-sharing site Flickr and bookmarking service Del.icio.us Inc. were acquired by Yahoo! Inc. of Sunnyvale, Calif., for $30 million apiece in 2005.

Some have already succeeded in attracting traditional venture firms for larger rounds in order to broaden their reach and scope: microblogging service Twitter Inc. of San Francisco, for example, took in a $5.4 million second round from Union Square Ventures of New York and Charles River Ventures of Boston last summer, then added a round of undisclosed size from Japanese investor Digital Garage in January and an apparent $15 million funding from Spark Capital of Boston in May, with an eye on international expansion.

Here are a dozen more social media companies seeking to follow the new paths beaten by those predecessors, each with only a few million dollars in funding but with key investors guiding them along their way. Their bellwether success or failure will augur the future of the new seed investment model, and reveal how typical, or extraordinary, their antecedent companies really are.

Big Head Labs Inc.

On some widely read, highly trafficked blogs, the real action is in the comments section. Disqus, the product of Big Head Labs Inc. of San Francisco, provides tools that enhance the commenting process, creating threaded discussions linked to user profiles that appear in popup windows. The idea is to create true conversations around blog posts, rather than simply lining up comments behind the original blogger's remarks.

Disqus was hatched by YCombinator, the bicoastal incubator that typically makes micro-investments in dozens of companies each year (see related story, page TK). First seeded in mid-2007, Disqus attracted $500,000 from Union Square Ventures in March 2008, in part due to the enthusiastic support of firm partner and popular blogger Fred Wilson. Since the investment, which also included Epinions Inc. co-founder Naval Ravikant, angel Aydin Senkut and hedge fund manager Howard Lindzon, Disqus has added a video comment feature via a partnership with Seesmic Inc.

Dogster

As the user counts for Facebook and MySpace.com continue to spiral upward, niche social networks focused on specialized interests stand out by cutting through the noise. Ergo, Dogster Inc. of San Francisco, a social network for dog owners (and dogs!) that became profitable before taking in any outside capital at all. Founded in 2004, Dogster went to the feeding dish for $1 million from angels, with former Goldman, Sachs & Co. Internet research executive Michael Parekh taking a board seat.

Jeff Clavier, who invested through his SoftTechVC fund, says about a sixth of Dogster's revenue comes from sales of virtual goods -- typically bones and toys -- featured on a dog's profile page, although the site also generates income from paid subscription services and advertising. The company lapsed out of profitability after its September 2006 angel round but returned just over a year later and has been consistently profitable since. And although Dogster caters to dog lovers, cat lovers need not feel left out: The company operates Catster as well.

Dopplr

Web communities may free friendships up from geographical boundaries, but there's still no substitute for hooking up face to face, or F2F, in Web-ese. For frequent travelers with friends all over the world, Dopplr Ltd. provides Web tools that help schedule and coordinate trips, stopovers and visits, for both business and personal reasons.

It's no surprise that a few well-traveled seed investors were among the first people to find Dopplr valuable, and the Helsinki-based company brought in Argentine entrepreneur Martin Varsavsky, LinkedIn Corp. founder Reid Hoffman, serial entrepreneur Joichi Ito and Saul Klein of London-based Accelerator Group as initial backers in a round of unspecified size in September 2007. Since then, it's added a bundle of new features but has yet to disclose its business model.

FriendFeed

If Twitter emerged as the must-have application at the South by Southwest conference in Austin during March 2007, FriendFeed Inc. of Mountain View, Calif., founded by four former Google Inc. executives, inherited the mantle at the 2008 convention. FriendFeed's application culls information from a user's friends' activities around the Web, centralizing them in a single convenient stream or dividing them into "rooms." The company has attracted special attention for being one of the few applications that bridges services available on the Web and those inside Facebook's walled garden, potentially making it a keystone property as Facebook, Google and others battle for advertising dollars and user mindshare.

Co-founder Paul Buchheit, who, incidentally coined Google's "Don't be evil" motto, was already an experienced angel investor before launching FriendFeed. Buchheit and co-founder Sanjeev Singh acted as FriendFeed's own angels until Benchmark Capital of Menlo Park, Calif., led a $5 million Series A round that rolled up their previous investments in February 2008.

MOG

Because so many people regard their musical taste as part of their identities, social networking and blogging are often closely tied to music. MOG Inc. of Berkeley, Calif., operates its own network of music blogs that feature streaming songs, allowing users to post their own favorites and listen to other people's while meeting fans with similar tastes. It's one of the only sites that wraps up music discovery, user-generated content and on-demand streaming in one place, thanks to a partnership with Real Networks Inc.'s Rhapsody music service.

MOG accepted $3.2 million in two rounds from the Angels' Forum, an affiliation of individual investors based in Palo Alto, Calif. This past spring, major record labels Universal Music Group and Sony BMG Music Entertainment, both of Los Angeles, kicked in the majority of a $2.8 million round that included further investment from the same angel group.

Outside.in

Neighborhoods are niches, and as the sheer amount of information on the Web grows, niches have become more important than ever. New York-based Outside.in Inc. aims to be a neighborhood information and services site, currently serving hundreds of districts in dozens of U.S. cities. Founded by Steven Johnson, author of "The Ghost Map" and other intriguing nonfiction books, Outside.in culls news stories, blogs, map and business data, and other neighborhood-specific information from around the Web, fostering discussions among local residents. It's almost a quaint irony that the 2.0-style site mirrors the way the original social networks were born: from knowing your neighbors.

In May 2008, Outside.in announced a $3 million Series A round that included venture firms Milestone Venture Partners and the New York City Investment Fund, both of New York, as well as Union Square Ventures and Betaworks, bringing its total funding to $5.4 million. The startup also hired former About.com general manager Mark Josephson as CEO. Futurist-journalist Esther Dyson, Netscape Communications Corp. author Marc Andreessen and Xerox Corp. Palo Alto Research Center director John Seely Brown were among its seed backers.

Pownce

Once regarded as a sort of enhanced Twitter copycat that mimicked the microblogging service but included attachments, San Francisco-based Pownce Inc. has taken big steps since it revealed its first outside funding in January 2008. The service, founded by programmer Leah Culver, Digg Inc. co-creator Kevin Rose and Digg creative director Daniel Burka, now allows users to share large files with each other and has opened a collaborative development platform.

Bootstrapped for about six months, Pownce took a small round of funding of undisclosed size from two investors who hold stakes in both Digg and Twitter, key Silicon Valley angel Ron Conway (see related story, page TK) and Maples Investments managing partner Mike Maples Jr. And as Pownce has made strides to differentiate itself from its better-known microblogging peer, Twitter's frustrating downtime issues and spotty service could soon prompt users to explore their tricked-out options -- even becoming paid power users of Pownce, giving the upstart an initial business model while Twitter has yet to reveal one.

Rapleaf

We all have online reputations, whether we choose to try to control them or not. Rapleaf Inc. of San Francisco provides a method of managing individuals' online reputations similar to eBay's Feedback feature while collecting information about them from around the Web and offering it up as a people-search service. The two-year-old company has collected $1 million in funding from PayPal co-founder and early Facebook investor Peter Thiel, as well as SoftTechVC, Conway, Senkut and Convergence Partners venture partner Eric Di Benedetto.

Like Facebook, Rapleaf knows the value of mining and harvesting vast amounts of information about people and centralizing it in searchable form. Rapleaf also operates Upscoop, which automatically searches for a user's contacts on a variety of social networks, and TrustFuse, which sells aggregated data to marketers. Some observers have floated privacy concerns about Rapleaf's projects, but the company maintains that it's "more profitable to be ethical."

Seesmic

Another Twitter descendant, Seesmic Inc. sports a video component that allows users to post short clips and create conversations. Founded by serial entrepreneur Loïc LeMeur, the company called on Skype Technologies SA founders Janus Friis and Niklas Zennstrom, as well as a dozen seed investors including TechCrunch blogger Michael Arrington, former America Online Inc. chief Steve Case, SoftTechVC, Hoffman and Conway, for $6 million in fall 2007.

Seesmic is used in the popular comments section of the TechCrunch blog and has designs on powering a variety of Web video services. To that end, it has already spent some of its money, acquiring microblog filtering service Twhirl this spring for an undisclosed amount.

SocialMedia

"When people say there is no way to make money on Facebook, I just laugh," says SoftTechVC's Clavier about portfolio company SocialMedia Networks Inc. "Those guys do one thing, which is help developers make money." The Palo Alto, Calif.-based startup is aiming to become the largest advertising network operating on social networks. It's benefited from Facebook's own growth, as well as the massive proliferation of applications that ride piggyback on the site's programming interface.

Ravikant, Google developer Jeremy Wenokur, Andreessen and SoftTechVC joined Charles River Ventures of Boston in a $4.5 million round formalized in October 2007. By the end of the year, Clavier says, the company had outpaced its own revenue projections for late 2008 and early 2009. SocialMedia faces tightening competition from widget marketers RockYou Inc. and Slide Inc., which also act as social ad networks, as well as ad marketplace Lookery Inc., another Charles River investment that is also backed by Betaworks, New York's innovative incubator.

Someecards

Some are snide, some are flirty, and some barely make sense -- but they're nearly all witty. The e-mail greeting cards created by Someecards Inc. of New York have grown virally over the past year, reaching about 1.5 million unique visitors per month this spring. That was enough to attract $350,000 in Series A funding from Betaworks, former Google Inc. executive Chris Sacca and Outside.in founding partner and documentary maker Mark Bailey.

Someecards' founders, former creative marketing directors Brook Lundy and Duncan Mitchell, only recently dedicated themselves full-time to Someecards. The still-tiny business is using the Series A round to hire a full-time Web developer, integrate with Facebook's platform, develop tools for user-generated content and build out its merchandising services. A second round could follow as soon as the end of 2008.

Tumblr

Spun out of Davidville Inc., the design company operated by 21-year-old founder David Karp, next-generation blog tool developer Tumblr Inc. appeared in early 2007. The site boasts an effortless interface for posting links, music and video files and traditional blog posts and adds a friend-following feature familiar to Twitter users.

The New York-based company looked to East Coast seed-stage specialists Spark Capital of Boston and Union Square Ventures and Betaworks for a $750,000 round last fall, alongside angels Vimeo Inc. founder Jakob Lodwick, Del.icio.us president Albert Wenger (now a partner at USV), former MTV Networks Co. executive Fred Seibert (Karp's mentor) and Varsavsky. -- Paul Bonanos



Seedlings
The growth of these 12 startups will say much about the new early-stage investment strategies
Company/
Location
Description
Most recent funding
Investors
Total funding ($mill.)
Big Head Labs Inc. (Disqus)
San Francisco
Enhanced blog comments
March 2008
Union Square Ventures, Naval Ravikant, Aydin Senkut, Howard Lindzon
$0.5+
Dogster Inc.
San Francisco
Virtual dog park
September 2006
Michael Parekh, SoftTech VC, Joshua Schachter, Adam Beguelin, Michael Tanne, Jim Young, Michael Arrington, Mike Jones, George Sarlo, Frank Caufield, Aydin Senkut, Brad Feld, Robert Simon
1.0
Dopplr Ltd.
Helsinki
Social calendar for world travelers
September 2007
Martin Varsavsky, Reid Hoffman, Joichi Ito, Accelerator Group
NA
FriendFeed Inc.
Mountain View, Calif.
Social media aggregator
February 2008
Benchmark Capital, Paul Buchheit, Sanjeev Singh
5.0
MOG Inc.
Berkeley, Calif.
Blogs and social networking for music fans
April 2008
The Angels' Forum, Universal Music Group, Sony BMG Music Entertainment
6.0
Outside.in Inc.
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Neighborhood info & services
May 2008
Union Square Ventures, Milestone Venture Partners, Betaworks, New York City Investment Fund, Esther Dyson, Marc Andreessen, George Crowley, Mark Bailey, Andrew Karsch
5.4
Pownce Inc.
San Francisco
Microblogging with attachments
January 2008
Ron Conway, Mike Maples
NA
Rapleaf Inc.
San Francisco
Reputation management and people search
June 2006
Peter Thiel, SoftTech VC, Ron Conway, Eric Di Benedetto, Aydin Senkut
1.0
Seesmic Inc.
San Francisco
Video microblogging
Fall 2007
Atomico Investments (Skype founders), Michael Arrington, Steve Case, SoftTech VC, Reid Hoffman, Ron Conway, Martin Varsavsky, Ariel Poler, Jeff Pulver, Dan Gillmor, Steve Garfield, Mark Pincus
6.0
SocialMedia Networks Inc.
Palo Alto, Calif.
Ad network for social networks
October 2007
Charles River Ventures, SoftTech VC, Mark Andreessen, Naval Ravikant, Jeremy Wenokur
4.5
Someecards Inc.
New York
Inbox humor
April 2008
Betaworks, Chris Sacca, Mark Bailey, Andrew Karsch, Nancy King
0.3
Tumblr Inc.
New York
Multimedia blog
October 2007
Spark Capital, Union Square Ventures, Betaworks, Jakob Lodwick, Albert Wenger, Fred Seibert, Martin Varsavsky
0.8

Source: The Deal


Comments
From: Peter,

People are also making money by using the social networks themselves, as users and advertisers.


From: Ashley Fidel,

Hello Paul,

I was reading your article “Social calling: a dozen Web startups put the new tech investment models to the test” and I thought it was very interesting because of my work in social media at JustMeans.

As you mentioned, entrepreneurship in social media is facing unique models of investment and innovation. At JustMeans, I work to use and incorporate these entrepreneurial strategies and also create positive social impact. The JustMeans platform creates networks and relationships, like Facebook or MySpace, but connects individuals and business solely around ideas and action in social responsibility.

If you think JustMeans could be interesting for your readers, let me know because I can line up a phone chat between you and our founder and CEO, Martin Smith, or a behind the scenes tour of our platform.

Thanks,

Ashley Fidel
JustMeans New York Associate
www.justmeans.com
afidel@justmeans.com


Post a comment



Search


The Tech Confidential Network
The Tech Confidential Network unites the leading voices from around the Internet on the topics of high-tech startups, venture capital and investment exits. Bloggers and publishers that want to expand their readership and monetize their content are encouraged to apply to join the Tech Confidential Network.


Video

Behind The Money: Iminlikewithyou's Charles Forman on selling virtual goods

cforman200.gif
Iminlikewithyou's Charles Forman on virtual goods and venture capital.
 




Windward Ho!

Startups In New York




Syndicate


Recent Entries
Categories
Monthly Archives

©Copyright 2008, The Deal, LLC. All rights reserved. Please send all technical questions, comments or concerns to the Webmaster.
Sponsored by