Back to News

Activist Investing Today: McRitchie Targets Shareholder Proposals

Published: January 22nd, 2021
James McRitchie, the top proponent of shareholder proposals, talks about what could happen if it becomes more difficult to submit proposals on environmental, social and governance issues.

The top proponent of shareholder proposals spoke with The Deal for its Activist Investing Today podcast about what he thinks would happen if the Securities and Exchange Commission made it more difficult to submit proposals on environmental, social and governance issues.

If investors were required to own 1% of a company’s shares to submit a nonbinding shareholder proposal, it would essentially eliminate the mechanism as it is known today.

That’s the view of James McRitchie, who has submitted hundreds of shareholder proposals at U.S. corporations over the past couple of decades. The publisher of CorpGov.Net talked about corporate shareholder proposals, resubmission thresholds and a controversial new statement of purpose issued by the Business Roundtable. In a wide-ranging conversation, McRitchie discussed what he thinks would happen to the shareholder proposal mechanism if the nation’s securities regulator issued new rules making it more expensive and increasingly difficult for investors to use.

“If it was anywhere near 1% to file, it would eliminate the whole thing because most proposals come from retail shareholders and the other large ones are from a few large pension funds,” McRitchie said.

On the podcast, McRitchie listed off the various groups that traditionally submit proposals, noting that even the largest employer of the investor mechanism, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, typically holds only one-fifth of 1% of a company.

McRitchie also criticized any regulatory effort that would make it difficult to resubmit shareholder proposals in subsequent years if they received a particularly low level of support. “As far as resubmission — a lot of things take time,” McRitchie said. “I’ve been filing proposals on transparency in political contributions. They have been getting low votes, in the single digits. But last year I finally won one. Social issues and corporate governance issues, a lot of that takes time.”

More podcasts from The Deal are available on iTunes, Spotify, and on

More From Podcasts

Mergers & Acquisitions

Drinks With The Deal: Mayer Brown's David Carpenter

By David Marcus
Published: April 15th, 2021
Carpenter, the co-head of Mayer Brown's New York corporate and securities practice, talks about his work for Nestlé, his love of wine and his involvement with SommTV in the latest episode of the podcast.

Activist Investing Today: Freed on Corporate Election Proposals, Risk

By Ronald Orol
Published: April 14th, 2021
The co-founder and president of the Center for Political Accountability discusses the growth in support for shareholder proposals urging companies to disclose election-related spending and why companies that don’t disclose these payments face political risk.

Drinks With The Deal: Duane Morris' Anastasia Kaup

By David Marcus
Published: April 8th, 2021
Duane Morris finance partner Anastasia Kaup talks about her practice, her work with the firm's diversity and inclusion committee, the importance of mentoring and her enjoyment of Krav Maga.