Back to News

Activist Investing Today: Columbia's Coffee on Board Diversity, Litigation

Published: December 6th, 2019
Part II of the Activist Investing Today podcast with Columbia Law School's John Coffee on why California corporations may decide against filing a lawsuit challenging a new board diversity requirement.

A lawsuit or two challenging California’s recently approved board diversity law is likely to emerge, though the proponents of such a challenge may not be immediately apparent.

At least that’s the view of Columbia Law School Professor John Coffee, who spoke with The Deal for its Activist Investing Today podcast about a new trend of legislators pushing to require corporations headquartered in their states to set up diverse boards. In California, a recently approved law requires one female to be installed on each locally-headquartered, publicly-traded corporate board by the end of this year. Coffee suggested that corporations based in the state without women directors may decide against filing a lawsuit challenging the restriction because of what he calls a “high embarrassment” cost.

However, he also suggested that “ideological organizations” on the right, such as the CATO Institute, may bring derivative actions, buying a small number of shares, and suing in the name of the company to contest the California law.

“It would require some degree of collusion between the company and investor, but it is possible we would see that as well,” Coffee said. “There is a quite uncertain future facing this legislation.”

Here’s the podcast:

Here’s some data about Illinois headquartered public companies and women directors:

More podcasts from The Deal are available on iTunes, Spotify, and SoundCloud and on

More From Podcasts


Activist Investing Today: AVI’s Bauernfreund on Japan Insurgencies

By Ronald Orol
Published: May 29th, 2020
The manager of a $1 billion sometimes activist fund discusses why he may submit shareholder proposals at Fujitec’s annual meeting in 2021 if it doesn’t consider divesting stakes, buy back shares, set up board subcommittees or perform a strategic review.

Drinks With The Deal Podcast: Penn's David Skeel

By David Marcus
Published: May 14th, 2020
David Skeel, a bankruptcy professor at the University of Pennsylvania, talks about his work with the Puerto Rico Oversight Board, lessons from 2008 and his thoughts on the potential fallout from the coronavirus.